Serious editing since I apparently talk too much...
what do you feed that has bone in it.
what do you feed that has bone in it.
Cool, there is no problem with that.When it comes to organs I feed, still, smaller amounts and typically do that on chicken days. I feed liver and whenever I can, kidney. (Typically I can only find them in beef or chicken flavors.)
I don't understand that because heart is the cheapest part of the cow around here, particularly because its all meat and fat and no bone. Remember, for our purposes, heart is not an organ ... its very rich meat and fat.We are currently working on beef heart and upping the amount to at least two-three bite sizes. Nonetheless, here, the beef heart is rather expensive. I don't know if I'll ever feed them an entire meal of beef heart because of it.
This is one of those trivial things that just doesn't matter. If you feed hardly any bone at all you are feeding all you need for the calcium. If you feed too much bone, the extra calcium is either stored in bones or excreeted via the kidneys. They don't build up too much calcium. They get rid of what they don't need. Again, this is mostly a poo thing and not a "what does the body need" thing.But that's the question...am I not feeding enough bone? What I mean is, should they be getting bone every meal or it is bone some days and the rest just meat and organs? Seems VERY expensive doing it this way.
I just get things labeled "pork ribs". I avoid "country cut" ribs which have short little ribs a couple of inches long. My dogs can and do swallow those thing whole. Just a slab of pork ribs is what I feed. I cut the slab in half and give each dog a half slab but im sure my dogs are a lot larger than yours. I don't know how many ribs you should give your dogs but when you figure it out by weight, cut that many ribs off the slab and hand it to them whole.I understand that I can give pork ribs and that will balance the meat and bone thing for a meal but I'm still, to this day, confused about WHICH ONE I can give. People keep saying something about how it's cut and to me, it all looks the same. Seriously. I don't understand what people mean about "jagged" cuts or edges because they ALL look like the same, to me. And what if the store doesn't have the one kind I'm allowed to give? What do I do then?
I don't personally feed beef RMB's. My dogs get all the bone they need from chicken. They do get bone in Boston Butt pork roasts once a week but some of those don't have any bone. They get a little bone in fish. I don't really care if they don't get any bone except whats in the chicken they get.I can't just give them chicken every day to try to get their bone to meat ratio right, (or turkey), so what do you all feed as far as other raw meaty bones? What do you feed beef wise that is a raw meaty bone? I can't give soup bones or weight bearing bones and apparently, from what I've read, I can't give them the beef ribs....so what do you give?
Depending on the size of the dog, you can feed the whole frame, or cut it in half with kitchen shears available real cheap at Walmart. If you have dogs that would eat a half a chicken in a meal, you can just cut the frame in halve leaving the legs and wings attached. Yes the frame has way too much bone but you balance that out by feeding boneless meals too.And, I'm also still hesitant about the bone even in chicken. Sometimes I will get a whole chicken, cause it's cheaper, and cut it up. I am a master at the legs and the wings, (wings for the cats), and the bag of goodies. But where I stall is the frame. I have, yes, thrown the entire thing out because I'm afraid it's too much bone.
I suspect a turkey wing is too much for a cat.What I typically do with a whole chicken, (or turkey), is cut off the legs for the hoodlums. I cut off the wings for the cats, (although with turkey, it seems I could give that to the hoodlums since it's a bigger wing?),
If that is the only thing you are feeding, then yes but remember, you are feeding boneless meals too. Don't worry about one meal being too boney or not enough bone. Worry about over time like a week or even a month.I cut off what I think is the thigh and give that to the hoodlums or the cats and I cut off the breast meat and whatever other tiny pieces of meat I can salvage. I'm then left with the frame. Isn't that too much bone and not enough meat?
Just cut it and don't worry about it. Thats one of those trivial things. Cut the wings and drumsticks off and the thighs if you wish then just cut the frame in half or feed the whole frame. IF you are feeding more than one part in a meal, TRY to leave them attached. In other words, you want to feed as large of pieces as you can. Idealy each meal would be only one piece. It's safer and more challenging for the dog and he enjoys playing with it more. :smile:And if it's not, how do I cut that up to give to all the pets? Am I not "splintering" the bone or giving it "jagged" edges if I do this? It seems too much to give to one animal, even the boy.
Don't throw ANYTHING away with few exceptions. Throw those big beef weight bearing bones away. Throw away those bones on pork chops. Cut the pork chop meat off the bone, feed the meat, throw away the bone. Other than that, I can't think of anything to throw away.I feel like I'm throwing things away that I could actually feed and wasting a lot of money but I'm just not really sure about the frame of a chicken or turkey, the beef ribs, the KIND of pork ribs I can give, what other bones with meat on them I can give.
Depends on the size of your dogs. My dogs eat it. Its a lot of work but they seem to enjoy it. They never get up and walk away from it.And with the pork shoulder picnic roast thingie, it has a thick layer of skin around one side of it. Typically I have cut this off and thrown this away. Should I be feeding it and if so, how much is too much skin?
Anytime you don't feel right about the bone because of its shape, just cut the meat off it and feed meat only.I've thought about pork chops...but the bone seemed weird so I passed. I've thought about cuts of beef but again, the bone was either round with the hollow center, (isn't that a sign of a weight bearing bone?), or weird cut and I was afraid to give it.
Pour yourself a glass of wine, sit down and enjoy it while the dogs eat and don't worry about it. I feed my dogs chicken, pork, fish, and beef heart, beef liver and venison when I can beg some off other people. I don't spend 5 seconds a month worrying about whether they are getting all they need. I attribute Abby's long life to her diet that she has been eating for 9 years now.What I'm doing now is I give chicken pieces, (or turkey), a few times a week that have bone and the rest of the week I give meat only meals...which is mainly pork from the roast thingie, very rarely beef because it's expensive and either gizzards, hearts, liver, kidney, whatever...but I can't shake this feeling that I'm wasting money somewhere and I'm not giving them things they could have and I'm not giving things I could be buying because I'm taking some of what I'm reading far too literally.
Rarely anything else.So, what do you give, for bone in meals, besides chicken and besides turkey?
Keep an eye out for sales and "expired" meats. Look for lamb. It is real expensive around here and I almost never feed it. It seems to be a lot cheaper in other parts of the country.I'm asking so that I know what other meats and cuts I can give and I'm asking about things I've typically thrown away that maybe I CAN feed them if I just know HOW to feed it. (Also, keep in mind, this is from the grocery store as I do not have, at this time, access to any other types of meat. I'm only asking about from the store.)
Oh!! I LOVE those for my guys! But I think it depends a lot on the size dog you are feeding - I cut most of the meat off, leave the bone fairly meaty, toss the bones in a freezer bag in the freezer and give them to the dogs to work over on the weekends when I'm here to supervise them. Takes them about 2 to 3 hours to eat the entire bone. They love it. And then they get a boneless dinner of pork meat. The fat doesnt bother my dogs, but I've never picked up any pork roasts of any kind that were insanely fatty. The most recent ones I picked up did have skin attached, and I just left it on when I cut it up (made them chew a little moreThe other thing I avoid is the pork shoulder roast, it has a lot of skin, fat, and a huuge bone, even if I use the fat/skin to make "chicharrones" and get myself fat, I end up throwing away the bone which makes up a nice portion of the weight that gets paid for.
But the way you determine that is by looking at their poo. You ask how do I determine the amount but don't tell me to look at the poo. Looking at the poo is how you determine it. There is no other answer.I asked about bones. I asked if I was not feeding enough. NOT because their poos are dusty or crumbly, their poos are fine..which is why I said I wasn't looking for an answer that said, "look at their poo".
Frames are boney. If all you fed were frames, you would be feeding way too much bone. Taking meat off for the cats doesn't help the situation. I feed my cats chicken drumsticks and it works fine. No need to give them meat from other parts of the chicken.I questioned chicken frames..was it too much...it still seems too much. By the time I get done taking off meat for the cats, there's not a lot of meat left on that frame..if any. Can I feed a naked frame?
Both ... most dogs handle beef ribs fine. Some might chip a tooth. It depends on the dog. Personally, I don't feed them, not because I'm concerned about my dog's teeth but because pork ribs are cheaper and easier to eat.I questioned ribs because people say jagged edge and cut wrong and the like. I've heard people say not to give beef ribs..and Molly Woppy presents why...her dog chipped a tooth. But some people say it's fine. Which is it?
I have read a lot of threads here about what people feed. That is the place to get that info but basically you can feed any meat you buy at the grocery store but watch out for those weight bearing bones.What prompted this thread was a) I feel like I'm not giving enough variety and maybe there are foods out there I don't know about or thought I couldn't feed that I can,
Yes there is a lot of skin on the shoulder roast. You don't have to feed it all at the same time. Cut off some of it and feed it with a frame or something else. Spread it out over several meals.b) I think I'm wasting where I don't have to and need to know HOW to feed what I think I've been wasting...ok, so they can eat the skin off the pork shoulder roast thing...but HOW much? It's a LOT of skin.
Yes, you are feeding more bone than they actually need. Most of us do, including me. In that PDF, what Tom is calling chicken and turkey carcasses is the same thing we call frames which you are feeding. Frames already have the human usuable meat removed. The meat is removed by machines and there is some meat left which is what we feed.And c) I read this site:
rawmeatybones and it seems that they are more about bones than meat. I opened a PDF and saw this:
"Chicken and turkey carcasses, after the meat has been removed for human consumption, are suitable for dogs and cats." (emphasis mine)
And I started to wonder...am I not giving them enough bone?
It seems different things are cheap in different parts of the country. I pay around $1/lb for beef heart in bulk but lamb is way way expensive here. Can't find any lamb for less than $4/lb ... most is more. Other places lamb is around $2/lb.Finally, I'm trying to find an economical way of doing this because it IS expensive for me. Beef hearts here are $2.99 a pound...so, no, not cheap.
Don't worry about bone. You are feeding plenty of bone in the chicken parts you are feeding. If you feed pork ribs, there is even more bone. Don't worry about looking for bone.It seems that if I can find other ways to feed bone with meat surrounding it, as I have read on this forum should be done, maybe this won't be so expensive.
Yes it is but that picnic roast that has that big bone in it would be close to the price of boneless meats if you bought it without the bone.It is expensive trying to find ways to give them boneless meals.
Most of what I feed IS chicken. I feed 14 meals a week to each dog and cat. 11 of those meals are chicken. I figure i can afford a pork meal & a beef heart meal & a fish meal a week. If you can get some other cut of beef cheaper, get it instead of heart. If you see something else on sale such as lamb at a reasonable price, get it.Perhaps if there was another protein source that has the meat and bone, such as the chicken has, it won't cost me so much. Is it worth it? YES! Can I continue to afford it...IF I can find a way to keep it economical. I need ideas. I don't think that is trivial.
(Waving hands in the air) I know!!!! I know!!! call on me!!! call on me!!! :biggrin: I suspect if you know who he is, it proves you are an old fart.Edit: Oh and PS, magicre, I have no idea who garrison keillor happens to be. ???
I second, third, and fourth this!!garrison keillor, serenity, is a magical being when it comes to stories.
he just has a way of talking, just as you have a way of telling a story....f