Dog Food Chat banner

How many is too many?

7.2K views 44 replies 10 participants last post by  meggels  
#1 ·
Is there a number that you feel is "too" much?

Reason I ask is that my friends think I'm insane because I've recently been given a really amazing situation and will be basically getting a third dog. Another frenchie named Irma. She is a show prospect, and will be a really great dog for me to get involved with, I've always been interested in showing, and she's also a really great candidate for rally obedience and agility.

They also say I'm gonna have a hell of a time finding an apartment someday, but I feel like I can't be the ONLY one to have a few dogs and need to rent?

Anyways, here's my new girl. I love her. She's very naughty :D

Image
 
#2 · (Edited)
There's such a thing as too many? I had no idea :eek: :tongue:

We are waiting for our next Dane puppy to arrive in the next 3-4 weeks. She will be the fifth dog of ours. As soon as we move to more land/space we will most likely add to the pack. I love watching our dogs interact with one another. They all have their places in the pack dynamic and it always makes me smile watching them all do their own thing. They are all so different in their own ways, I love them all for this.

ETA: I forgot the two cats LOL
 
#5 ·
Honestly, I wanted to stick with two, but this was too good of an opportunity to pass up. I paid basically nothing for her, will be added as a co-owner to her papers, but will have custody of her. She's a REALLY nice dog imported from Poland, and she's a great first dog for me to get into showing with, something I've always been interested in. She will only go back to my friend for breeding *depending upon her passing her health testing at 1 year old*, she will take care of all the finances involved with that. And god forbid I move, and need Irma to be taken care of for awhile, I'm sure my friend would do it, no questions asked.

Need to come up with a new name for her now....
 
#11 · (Edited)
She's a REALLY nice dog imported from Poland
Polish imports are great! That's where I got my husband!

Sorry, I couldn't resist. :biggrin: I don't have much constructive input for ya!

ETA: Ooh! Actually I do! I have always liked the name Jezabel if it fit the personality. You could call her Jezzy or Jez for short.
 
G
#15 ·
Is there a number that you feel is "too" much?

I always thought I would have just one or two dogs, but I have three. For me, three is plenty.

I'm friends with a lady that lives alone with her pack of 17 dogs. That, to me, is too much. The fact that she lives alone in addition to the fact that her home isn't in the best of condition. It smells awful, it's dirty, and the dogs are dirty and smell bad. She has a HUGE fenced-in yard, but, she did not know that there was a dead raccoon in her yard, not far from the house, until someone pointed it out to her. I think she is overwhelmed. She works all day so most but not all of the dogs are crated in the basement.
 
#16 · (Edited)
I'd say that women is a "collector"!

Meggels, I only ask about the finances because I think you posted in another link that finances are an issue for you, and one of my big issues with people and pets is yes, they will love them with their whole being, but if something drastic were to happen (hit by a car, cancer, any other surgery) they don't have the finances to do it. You had even posted that good food was an issue because of finances, I don't want to be the black sheep but when you work with rescue you always ask yourself these questions of others, so please don't take it personally, I'd ask anyone this who had asked the same questions.
 
#17 ·
I think 3-4 Dogs is about the cutoff for a "normal" existence. (I have 3)...I say "normal" not in any insulting way...

only that if you have more than that...you really need to do some pretty hardcore logistical planning...feeding, how you are going to live, financial impact, what would the arrangement be if something happened to you-where would the Dogs go, how you are going to control them and keep them safe, VET bills, etc...I just think it takes a little more foreward thinking.

BUT, if someone is willing to put in the effort, I think a person could have about as many as they could handle without getting too crazy(10+)
 
#23 ·
No no no. I live with ALL of them now haha. I live with about 15 dogs right now, including my two, Abbie & Murph. I'm living with my friend, who is a breeder, who owns Irma.

But yeah, I think I'm gonna decline :( Bummer, but I think it's best.
 
#29 ·
I have to jump in and say that I agree with the logical thinkers here Meggels.

I used to have a French Bulldog. Great dog but she sure came with health problems. Allergies (she was a pied, so that's typical), stenotic nares (had to be especially careful in the summer), and she ended up with intervertebral disc disease as she aged. Typical, normal things for a Frenchie, but her vet bills were extravagant.

And no, she wasn't poorly bred, she was actually my first show dog and she finished her championship, owner handled, as a puppy and went on to a short specials career with a group 3 and 4. Beautiful dog. It's just the breed.:frown:

She was bred, per my contract with her breeder and co-owner, 3 times but never conceived. Two were artificial inseminations with frozen semen and the third was a natural breeding with a proven stud dog. This alone cost several thousand dollars.

Anyway, sorry to ramble - but frenchies are not the easiest or healthiest breed and adding another when finances are tight is never a good idea. So I think you are doing the right thing.
 
#30 ·
Ha Late here with a response to the original question. I have right now 4 dogs Have had 5 kids Have had a rabbit, had 4 guinea pigs right now have 1, fish tanks 3 set up right now and going for #4, snake but no more, lizards have only the veiled chameleon now, my one daughter had a cat no more gave it to a neighbor~ hmmmm what else think that's it but if I am wrong I will correct this haha!
But anyway what's right for you is what you should go by not anything is wrong or right:tongue:! A woman when I walk the dogs said 4 is ok but when you get to 5 your a hoarder. She works for The animal welfare league or I should say volunteers. But well I just said that's ok for them whatever they think, but I go by what I can handle and what I feel is right! :cool:Well obviously I like to go for the gusto and go big:biggrin:! A third dog will do fine with your dogs! I have not read all the posts so this is for the first post! Good luck with your new furbaby!:wink:
 
#31 ·
I think I’m gonna pass for now. At least until I know more about where my life is going lol. I also think I need to stay committed to my other two. I hope to have Abbie as a rally or agility prospect once she continues to become less nervous in public. And Murph would be great for obedience since he’s so food driven haha. I wish I could do agility with him cause he would kick ass, he’s so fearless, but Lesa said it probably wouldn’t be good for his bum patella :(

Plus, I was laying in bed with Murph today and just sorta felt this guilt, like he’s the only smushy faced pup for me. I lucked out with him. He’s so loveable. He’s active (well, as active as a frenchie can be lol), but also quiets right down and loves to snuggle, he’s very affectionate, friendly and somewhat smart for a bully breed haha. I was napping with him today, except for some reason he refuses to sleep, so I’ll crack an eye open and he just sits and stares at me while I sleep lol. And then when he sees that my eyes are open he pounces on me and kisses me. Le sigh. I love him.

I LOVE HIM. I almost don’t want to devote my love to any other frenchie LOL.

Image

Image

Image


And my girl Abbie, I have high hopes for her if I keep socializing her and getting her over her fear issues.

Image
 
#33 ·
Thanks for sharing....very sweet story! And what a handsome boy Murph is! Love is little squishy face :wink:

When I got home from work today, I just went to lay down in bed for a few. Not even a minute later ALL four of the girls came a snuggled me in bed. It was perfect. Each one of them had their place around me, Shiloh always has to be right on top...which wouldn't be such a huge deal if she didn't have such "sharp" elbows that dig in! A Dane at each of my arms. And of course Emmy up at my face. If I stop petting her she taps me with her paw telling me not to stop LOL, Shiloh does the same but she has ninja like grip with her paws (I think she thinks she has thumbs). It was so peaceful that we all just fell asleep :biggrin:
 
#38 ·
Awww. Yeah, I think I need to stick with my two. I still have work to do with my girl Abbie. She was rescued from Arkansas, her siblings and her were at a kill shelter and luckily someone pulled them! Breaks my heart to think she might not be with me today if someone hadn't gotten them in time. I've had her since January, and it's been a struggle, but she is slowly but surely making progress. I've never had experience with a shelter dog, let alone one who has such fear/anxiety issues. She's very wary of strangers, loves other dogs (as long as they aren't too in your face), seems to prefer women to men, but I'm definitely her person. She's very loyal to me. I like to think it's cause we have a connection, but realistically, it's probably because I was home with her the first few days she came to live with us haha.

But she has definitely has made progress since January, and from what I've read, it seems that it can be kind of a long road to get them over their issues. I guess in the first home she was in (for only a few weeks) she was always hiding under the bed.

The biggest issue I have now is that she barks when people approach us in the house. If one of the men in the house walks into the room, she starts barking at them. If someone comes into my room she goes ballistic. Any tips on how to stop this?

Anyways, here's my little girl. Dunno what her mix is. I think hound & herding dog of some sort. She's so smart, and watching her interact with other dogs, makes me think of a herder. But she seems to keep her nose glued to the ground when we're outside haha.

Image

Image

Image

Image