Petcurean foods are made by menu the one who had all the recalls in 2007. I do not know how they are now though! I would check into it and menu may be fine now. I am just leery of menu products with all their recalls in 2007 but hey its 2009 now so who knows. I am sure someone may have more info. for you! I love Innova but I have no info other than knowing menu foods had tons of recalls back in 2007 and petcurena which is made by menu I have not ever used this product! Check out some sights on menu and petcurean! What I see sounds like a great product grainless and good but I know with high protein contents you need to be careful with large breed pups I know if its too high in protien should be for adult dogs only! But you said its the same as your feeding so should be fine then! But from what I have seen seems like a great food!